Dennis Anderson
See more of the story

SPANISH WELLS, BAHAMAS – Roy Pinder eased his sleek 25-footer from the dock and motored through the harbor here past the big boats from which he dove for lobsters for more than 30 years, living on board for up to a month at a time.

On this day in the harbor in addition to Roy's boat and the big lobster boats, a few pleasure yachts were tied up whose transoms bear the names of distant ports. Also smaller boats abound, some used by conch fishermen but most owned by sport anglers and rigged for wahoo, grouper, snapper and the like.

The wind was up and would build throughout the day. Not too much wind for Roy's boat, but by contrast the few Spanish Wells flats skiffs that cater to bone fishermen when the wind is quieter were knotted to docks.

Roy, who is 73, earns a living in his boat ferrying tourists to nearby islands. Visitors stroll on endless sand beaches or snorkel or feed squid to stingrays that swarm around the tourists' legs. Also, pigs inhabit one island and photo-snapping tourists swim with them and feed them as well.

"The swimming-with-the-pigs-thing is lost on me," said Barb Hexum.

Barb and her husband, Tom, of Rochester, Minn., were on Roy's boat as well and have been coming to Spanish Wells for decades. Not quite 2 miles long and a quarter-mile wide, Spanish Wells is reached only by boat and has no casinos, golf courses or, really, anything to do after 5 p.m. except eat, read or sleep.

"Quiet is the way people like it here," Tom said.

A Spanish Wells native, Roy has been in and on water his entire life. As a boy, he learned to free dive without air tanks or compressors because there were none. By the time he was 15 or 16 and certainly by 17 he could hold his breath and dive 70 feet, a skill that, with a speargun in his hand, or Hawaiian sling as they're called, could bring him to within shooting range of hogfish, snapper and grouper. Spearing one of these near the ocean bottom, Roy, while still holding his breath, would surface with his impaled quarry. Sometimes while ascending, blood clouds arose from the speared fish and the blood attracted sharks. If the sharks couldn't be bullied into leaving, Roy moved his boat and with his speargun dove elsewhere.

This strategy worked except when it didn't, and it didn't on June 25, 1968, when Roy was 17 and diving with a friend for grouper on a cooker of a day beneath a new moon.

Roy had speared a grouper, a big one, 40 feet down when a Caribbean reef shark, or perhaps a silky shark, attacked him head-on, its jaws quickly opening before closing around Roy's head and tearing at it and also at his face.

Dropping his spear while continuing to hold his breath, Roy grasped the shark's jaws with his hands, trying to free his head. Seeing the attack, Roy's companion jumped into the water and shot the shark with his spear. The shark then turned on Roy's companion, its mouth open and charging, and the companion shot a second spear into its gaping maw and down its throat.

Waters around Spanish Wells probably represent the best overall fishing in the Bahamas, especially for lobsters. But notwithstanding the bonefish caught here on a fly on the flats off Spanish Wells, the island ranks behind South Andros...
Waters around Spanish Wells probably represent the best overall fishing in the Bahamas, especially for lobsters. But notwithstanding the bonefish caught here on a fly on the flats off Spanish Wells, the island ranks behind South Andros...

Dennis Anderson

On plane now, Roy's boat divided waves of warm salt air that folded neatly around its center console. In all directions clear blue water blended to turquoise and aquamarine while Roy circled the turtle- and pig-swimming island before turning the boat toward Eleuthera, the larger island adjacent to Spanish Wells. There he found a watery cut that divides the Caribbean from the Atlantic and guided his boat through it before killing the outboard and settling the watercraft into Eleuthera's leeward waters.

"That's where it was,'' Tom said, pointing to a swath of beach where his dad owned a resort until Hurricane Andrew flattened it in 1992.

In summers when he was a kid after Tom got out of school in Rochester he came and went to the Bahamas resort with his parents, goofing off there, swimming and fishing as kids do and passing the good time.

In the decades since, he and Barb have traveled to Spanish Wells during Minnesota's cold months, holing up for a time in a rented oceanside bungalow while relishing the island's retro vibe and befriending its locals, Roy among them.

As Roy turned his boat back toward Spanish Wells the wind as forecast blew briskly and the ocean gained a chop that was new to the day. Attempting to circumnavigate Devil's Backbone on the north end of Eleuthera we instead turned back because the wind was too strong and the waves too steep. When we tooled into Spanish Wells harbor, Roy tied up his boat and we disbanded before gathering a short while later with Roy's wife, Linda, over conch fritters and mahi-mahi tacos.

"What happened after the shark attack when you got back to Spanish Wells?'' I asked Roy.

"By the grace of God, a group of American divers were on the dock,'' Roy said. "One was a medical student who pressed against an artery in my head that was bleeding, saving my life until I got to a hospital. It took 400 stitches to sew up my face.''

"When they finally let me in the hospital to see him, he didn't look human,'' Linda said.

But Roy healed up, and for more than 30 years, kept diving.